April
8, 2003 -- Establishing and maintaining an effective
audit committee has become a hot topic in today’s business
environment. One important way for your board to acknowledge
and respond to its public accountability is to establish a
well-focused audit committee.
Oftentimes, audit committee functions and financial oversight
are performed by the entire board. However, many boards have
realized the usefulness of a separate, distinct audit committee.
This group is charged with a very specific purpose—to
ensure the organization’s audit is adequate and to understand
the organization’s financial risks and its responses
to those risks.
Consider the following when organizing an audit committee:
- An audit committee should include at least three directors.
A smaller group may not provide enough varying perspectives.
- It’s useful to have a senior board member participate
on the audit committee. Historical perspective could prove
to be useful in asking the right questions of management and
the auditors.
- Audit committee membership should rotate in a manner
that provides both continuity and “fresh eyes”
each year. The chairperson should have served at least one
year on the committee.
Once the committee is established, its responsibilities should
be documented for new member orientation purposes, as well
as to remind members and management what their roles are.
Consider including the following:
- The audit committee should be advised by management
when changes to the accounting principles or policies are
considered, particularly if the changes have a material effect
on the financial statements as currently reported.
- The committee should be notified immediately about
fraud or transactions or events that could create exposure
to the Board.
- The audit committee should receive assurance that
the organization complies with its contractual obligations.
- Management should brief the committee on the internal
control environment. Management also needs to provide assurances
to the committee about the effectiveness of internal controls.
- The audit committee will recommend to the board the
selection, retention or termination of the organization’s
outside auditors. Frequently, the audit committee will be
involved in requesting audit proposals and/or reviewing those
proposals. It may be very useful for the committee to meet
each prospective audit team to assess its responsiveness to
the organization’s needs.
- Pre-audit meetings with the audit firm and management
can be useful. At a pre-audit meeting, the audit committee
and auditors should discuss the scope of the audit and identify
any specific concerns. The audit committee may identify specific
controls it would like the audit firm to consider in more
depth than would be required by the standard audit.
- The audit committee should review audited financial
statements and management letter reports to verify that they
faithfully reflect the past year’s transactions and
events. At least one face-to-face meeting with the auditors
a year is recommended. That meeting should focus on reviewing
the results of the audit. The committee should also expect
the audit firm to provide the following information, as required
by the professional standards of auditors:
- the firm’s responsibilities under generally accepted
auditing standards,
- changes in the organization’s significant accounting
policies and their applications,
- use of management judgments and estimates in the financial
reporting process,
- audit adjustments and differences,
- management’s consultation with other accountants,
or issues discussed in connection with the retention or appointment
of the auditors, and
- other matters considered necessary by the auditors.
- The audit committee will prepare a report to the board
at the end of the audit process. The report should document
the committee’s acceptance of the audit firm’s
reports and identify any significant areas that the board
should address.
Each board member has the fiduciary duty to assure financial
accountability. A governance structure that includes an audit
committee demonstrates the board’s commitment to its
fiduciary duties.
Back to 2003 News
|